I'd get a marlin. I'd also look for a used one if a new one cost too much. The marlins are forged steel and walnut. They will last many generations. My Dad bought me a 39a for my 13th birthday and now 23 years later and many, many thousands of rounds later it is still going strong. You can also clean the 39 from the breech if you like.

The browning is nice except for the "made in japan" on the barrel. I don't mind my electronics or motorcycles to come from japan, but not a true American icon like the lever action rifle.