The first deer was 3.5 years old. The others, 2.5, granted the last one could have been from injury, but im seriously doubting it, no injury or scarring to speak of, no other deformitys other than the antlers. And the 2nd deer is a no brainer,In its second year, itshorns were not even big enough to tag as a buck, not to mention they go every which way.. And i stumbled across a trail cam pic.. and this one you think is not a cull deer either?? Before you say its a young deer look at the size of its head and for around here, with the size of that deer,i can honestly tell you that is not his first set of horns.