I agree antlers do not size up the deer. However I have shot a deer with one antler being six points with a drop. The other antler apeared to have been shot off by someone. That deer dressed out 245lbs. Next was an eight pointer that dressed out at 203lbs. While a friend weighed his eleven pointer weighing in at 187 lbs. Antlers in this case didn't make any sence to me, as the eight pointer outweighed the eleven pointer.