ORIGINAL: Talondale
I won't argue that point with you Greg, a compound is a more precise weapon.
Following your logic why would anyone useANY bow over a gun? A gunCAN (in the hands of a proficient, ethical shooter) certainly be more humane than a bow. Why do you use a bow? I think it's because you get more out of your hunt when you use one. Same reason applies to traditional. Neither one is the "right" answer for everyone. In this case it is relative and everyone hopefully finds their own niche that they enjoy, and they are able to have fun.
Because guns are not legal during bow season. You are also right, archery is enjoyable. However, I'm undecided on what is more important, using a more primative weapon in order to gratify yourself or to show respect for the animal by using the most efficient, legal weapon to kill it with.