Well, I also hunt OH, although unsuccessfully. The think I see here is that you want something you can get out and get on target faster than a self defense gun! Really! For that, something like the Ruger/Accusport Bisley in 45 Colt with adjustable sights, 5.5" barrel and SS finish is great. I think they are readily available now days. You can shoot mild 45 Colt loads and still have good power, or you can shoot 320gr lead solids at 1300 fps like I do and feel it blow the 44mag away in terms of recoil! Normal 45 Colt HP loads should have much less recoil and should put the normal 15 - 50 yd OH deer down fine. With practice, you can safely get the hammer cocked when ripping it out of the holster in under 1s.