You'd think this would be an easy answer. Even though this years buck scores higher, I consider my buck last season to be bigger because had it not had a messed up side it would have beat this years by 10". I'll post both stats.

State: PA
Date: 11/05/05
Time: 3:45 pm
Points: 12
Score (if known): ~133
Age (if known): 4.5 (according to taxidermist)

State: PA
Date: 10/31/06
Time: 3:35 pm
Points: 9
Score (if known):~136
Age (if known): 3.5/4.5 (my estimate, waiting to see what taxidermist says)