I have 3 xbows, all Excals, one of which is a compound. The other two are a Phoenix and an Emax. If I only had one, it would be the Phoenix. It's lighter than the wheel bows, as accurate as anything sold, great trigger and easy to maintain at home. At one time, they could be had new for $349 on Ebay at bowhuntersuperstore. I like the fact that all Excals have the exact same great trigger. I also use the V-zone on all three, only $79.95 at same site. All the bows you listed are good ones and all will shoot completely thru the game you are hunting, it's really a matter of how far you want to go look for the arrow, how much you want to spend, and how they feel to you when you hold them up to shoot.