Before buying either... Look at the climbing sticks by Gorilla. The only two places I have found them are at Gander and at Farm&Fleet. They are 4 ft long, only cost 12.99 per stick so you can buy as many as you want. I bought eight and I have 3 on one tree and 5 on the other. They are by far the best I've seen/used and with the price a way better deal than either of the ones you are looking at.