I would have to see pics to buy that one. I have seen and taken some pretty big bodied deer and I have also heard a lot of stories about how much a deer weigh. Most of the "200 lbs" deer that I have seen have weighed less then 170lbs when you get them on a scale. 170lbs 1.5 year old is a little hard to swallow. 200 lbs doe?? If it is true good for you but it is a little hard to believe. Idon't thinkmany hunters have a good grasp on deer weights.