Maybe you should think about how you react to people's answers while you're sitting down thinking about why you hunt. Especially after you say "I'll be happy with whatever you guys tell me." I don't think Washington Hunter was trying to slam you. He posted the same thing I was thinking and I imagine alot of others are thinking, too. Why are you hunting? For meat? For horns? For respect from someone? For enjoyment? What are the genes like in your area? Would you be happy with that deer? Are you going to regret shooting it as opposed to letting him walk and hopefully make it another few years? Those are questions only YOU can answer and to be honest, what ever we say shouldn't really matter. Good luck and good hunting.