RE: would you shoot this deer?
what is your hunting goals ? if you want some meat, shoot. if you're looking for a specific deer, don't. If you have only a buck tag, or doe tag, shoot accordingly. If your season just started and you want it to end soon, shoot. If you want it to last, don't shoot.
its not black and white, many people take to the woods with tags and all for different reasons
Me ? Depends on where I'm hunting and why. Friday - I'll shoot. Next weekend in KS, the doe I wouldn't, the buck would need to be 140" or bigger.