I ended up going with the Wingmaster. It was a tough call, but I'll be using it for pheasant, chucker, etc. rather than duck/geese hunting. The 3" should suit me for a while. I like the feel of the Wingmaster. Entirely a personal, subjective thing, but you gotta make a some point. Guess that's why there are so many out there.

I plan on putting a rifled barrel on it at some point. Some of the pig hunting areas out here are shotgun/bow only. Oh well, another toy to buy!