I would go with the 870. If you want to spend a little more you can get it camo. I like the camo because it doesn't rust. I have an 870 3 1/2. and it is the best gun for the money. I have one that is blued and not camo. It is rusting a little but a little rust won't hurt anything. If you get camo it won't rust. I got my express super magnum for $265. In my opinion it is the best all around gun. I can use it for any type of hunting I want.