RE: Which would you choose?
I'd say the Springield XD 40 as well. I have the tactical model, and I love it. I would also suggest not gettin the ported model. Way too much more noise, and if you are in a low light condition you will never see the sights after the first bang. If recoil and gettin on target is an issue to you, try a Don's Stainless guide rod and a Wolfe 22# spring.