RE: Which would you choose?
Ugh. Nothing but double actions.
Try a Para-Ordnance P16-40. Single action, double stack, 1911. Shoot it in competition and you'll shoot rings around those other pistols you named.
IPSC/USPSA had to make "special" classes for double actions because they are not competitive with 1911's. Kinda like putting Corky in a Quantum Physics class.