It depends on whether you shoot right handed or lefty. The Easton chart says if your BH's are hitting left of your field points that you are having stiff spine reaction. To correct this you{ this is for righties }
1} Increase bow poundage
2} Increase BH weight
3} Decrease tension in cushion plunger
4} Move the arrow rest or cushion plunger in TOWARDS the bow. Make adjustments 1/32" at a time.

I just started learning the tuning guide last year and I am no expert by any meansbut it sounds like you are using the paper tuning method of moving your rest to the left to correct a left miss, when you actually should be using the broadhead tuning which says to move your rest to the right to correct a left miss.
I hope I'm not steering you wrong or confusing you. Good luck.