Sorry, just now saw your follow-up question. Between the two, most definitely Predator Fall Gray. I do think ASAT 3D is a lot better than the regular ASAT (I just can't get past the basic monotone background of ASAT, and that's also why I don't like Natgear). The geographic blocks which comprise the background is the best thing about Predatory Fall Gray; THAT'S what breaks the pattern up so well. The black "sticks and limbs" are just icing on the cake.