Well, the Encore pro hunter is expensive and will require an atf firearms form to be filled out since it has a serialed frame and can be converted to a rifle, pistol, and shotgun. I have no experience with the White rifles just what I have read which is good. The problems with the companywould affect me buying one as my first muzzleloadersimply for that reason. Maybe as a second or third like stated by another. The Savage is a strong muzzleloader and has the capability of using backpowder, substitutes, and smokeless which is a plus. They have an excellent trigger if you get one of the new ones. I have seen some video hunts where extreme shots have been made with these rifles not saying that the other brands wont because Ive seen some ofthem doit too. I personally would go with a regular encore frame and buy the pro hunter barrel myself at a cheaper price. Your going to pay more for that engraved frame. The barrels will fit any frame in the encore line i.e.,(pro hunter, regular stainless, regular blued). Also, with the encore you have the options of having a pistol, rifle, and shotgun by just spending another 200.00 to 300.00 on a barrel, sometimes alot cheaper if you find them used or on sale. I would vote for the encore. I have one in rifle, pistol, and soon to be muzzleloader. They have really treated me well on warranty work. They have one of the best service departmentsin the business.Remember, buy your frame and then buy the pro hunter barrel unless you really want the engraved frame. My 2 cents. Good Luck!!!!