Man charged in killing of Vermont BowHunter
Hunter charged in arrow death
November 7, 2002
(from the Front Page section Rutland Herald)
By BRENT CURTIS Herald Staff
Two years after an arrow killed a Rutland man, police arrested the hunter who shot him.
State Police arrested Joseph A. Teer Jr., 31, of Middletown Springs on Thursday on a charge of involuntary manslaughter for the killing of Thomas Fiske.
Teer was arrested at work in Rutland, but he was released soon after with a citation to appear in Rutland District Court on Tuesday to be arraigned.
Fiske, 36, died on the morning of Oct. 12, 2000, while hunting deer in the woods off Stevens Road in Pittsford.
Teer, who was also hunting the woods, told police he shot an arrow at a deer but it ricocheted and struck Fiske, who was in a tree stand 20 feet off the ground. The two men didn't know each other, police said, and each were unaware of the other's presence in the woods.
But Vermont State Police and Rutland County State's Attorney James Mongeon decided that Teer knew more than he was telling.
In an affidavit filed Thursday in Rutland Superior Court, Sgt. Ronald Crossman wrote that Teer couldn't have killed Fiske from the spot he claims to have shot from — whether the arrow ricocheted or not.
Using surveyor's reports, forensics data from the company that manufactured the arrow Teer used, conclusions of a bow hunting expert and other data collected by police and state game wardens during an exhaustive two-year investigation, Crossman concluded that Teer was shooting into the tree Fiske was sitting in.
"The evidence does not support the claims by Mr. Teer. … The evidence does support that the arrow was shot … in a direct line to an intended but unidentified target," Crossman wrote.
The investigation has been the most thorough — and in many ways troublesome — investigation of a hunting incident that State Police have conducted to date, according to Detective Lt. Myles Heffernan.
"It took longer than expected," Heffernan said Thursday. "It was more of a progression. It was difficult to locate sources and there was very little facts or data to look at. We didn't have the kind of data that we would generally have if this were a situation involving a gun."
A physics professor, for example, was asked for help at the beginning of the investigation, but wasn't able to offer conclusive evidence, Heffernan said.
"There wasn't a lot of cases to compare this to," he said. "There were only a few bow hunting incidents we could find and we couldn't find any with charges filed from them."
Heffernan said the felony count leveled against Teer was more severe than most charges brought against hunters who unintentionally kill another hunter. If convicted of involuntary manslaughter, Teer would face a minimum one-year jail term and a maximum sentence of 15 years in prison and a $3,000 fine.
"The degree of negligence in this case was greater than in other accidental shootings," the detective said. Heffernan said he could only recall one other occasion when a hunter was charged with involuntary manslaughter. In that case, the detective said a hunter lied to police, telling them that he discovered the body of a hunter who had been shot when, in fact, he shot the man.
Mongeon would say little about the felony charge, other than to say it fit the crime.
"If it was purely an accident, that would be different. A criminal charge implies culpability," he said.
Fiske's family was informed about Teer's arrest by police, said Brenda Wilk, Fiske's sister.
"We're happy that something is happening and we're waiting to see what happens from here," she said in a phone interview Thursday.
She said her brother's death had been hard on the family. Fiske ran a bow hunting shop with his brother and was a constant presence in his parents' home, she said.
"It was an awful thing," she said. "It's been hard, but the police have been good at communicating with us. It's taken a long time, but no one has been killed quite this way before."
Wilk said family members would be at Teer's arraignment on Tuesday.