I think they should have a couple of pro hunters on the show. Hunters that are used to being in front of the camera. The ave Joe, including me would be very nervous being on national TV and would probably not do as well stating what will probably be the opposing view.
Maybe The Drury brothers, Ralph and Vickie,Cuz,Toxey,Will Primos would be good choices?
We could always sik Uncle Ted on them?

It would be hard for us ave guys to not come off as an ass if the intent of a professional interviewer is to make us look that way. A good interviewer can manipulate and spin the interview the direction they want it to go. That is their job and some are very good at it.