If there positive its a 4.5 year old, its a different buck... Ask them if it lives in the Fountain city area. Thats where the one we have been watching lives. I last seen the buck two seasons ago and it was in the 170 class range as a 10 pointer, my buddy picked up the sheds, one even still had some white hairs around the pedical. I also seen a pic floating all over the internet last year with that buck and those antlers... This rack looks very simalar, but slightly larger. My buddy said it was a 180 class last year though?