I have no real use for maximum loads in the 45-70, but 200 FPS is a lot, especially when it's a considerable percent of gain. The Ruger #1 isn't something I feel would be as effective in the brush, I know that having just 1 shot will haveyou think about your shot a little bit more, but in thewoods I might need more than 1 shot. I guess it's between the Marlin Guide Gun or just the normal one withthe 22" barrel.