Wow.... Your Reflex Highlander is identical to mine (but they cranked it up to 68#). If you are absolutely positively left eye dominant, then by shooting righty, you are cross-shooting (I think that's the term for it). It is very difficult to train your right eye to overcome the power of the left eye.

For me, I can't hit the broadside of a barn righty... No matter what it is, archery, rifles, handguns, even shooting skeet with a shotgun. I'm one of those "weird" guys where I just HAVE to be lefty - ain't no way around it.

Too bad your in Pittsburgh and I'm down here in Richmond, VA. I'd like to let you try out my left handed Highlander compared to your right handed one and see what you think. It's all based on feel. One way will feel incredibly better than the other. Look at me with the sport of golf. Remember where I said I'm lefty? But with golf, I play righty. I couldn't even imagine trying to swing a golf club left handed... [&:]

Anyway, what I would do is go back to the bow shop and ask to try a lefty model and see how that feels to your right handed model. I have a funny feeling that the lefty model might feel a little better because your natural left eye dominance will be able to relax and focus clearly on the target without interference from your right eye.

Good luck and enjoy your Highlander!!!! [8D]