Wow... I can't believe the group I just got! This is mind boggling to the point where just I don't understand it....
Normally, my bow calculated to be roughly 272 fps with 100 grain tips and a little light (about 10.17% FOC) for hunting purposes. So out of curiosity, I screwed in some old 125 grainers and to play around with. According to calculations, a 125 grain would put me about 268 fps and a nice 12.68% FOC.
The below picture is two Beman ICS Hunter 340's at 25 yards with 125 grain tips! I even buggered up one fletching on the first arrow!!

I think I found my bow's true niche... It seems to like 125 grain tips more than 100 grain...
Now all I have to do is adjust my sight pin a tad and I'm good to go! [8D]