Don't get me wrong, the 44 mag is plenty of gun for deer and even elk and moose. There is no doubt about that. My interest in the 454 is simply that I have never tried one and I like the feel of the Raging Bull. As far as one to carry a lot, either the 4-5 inch Smith or the Blackhawk is my idea of a portable carry gun for hunting. Thats my weight limit for a backup gun.