"If it were manditory for everyone to report regardless if one killed a deer or not we could put to rest the accusations that the PGC is fudging the numbers."

I hate to be the bringer of news in this way, but it is mandatory to send in a harvest report when you harvest a deer. Here, from the digest you got with your Pennsylvania license to hunt:

"Within 10 days, hunters must report deer harvests to the Game Commission in Harrisburg using the report card supplied with each hunting license."

Not reporting your kill makes you a violator of the law. A violator of the law is an outlaw. Now, do those of you who don't send in your report cards feel better since you know what you are?