ORIGINAL: whitetailman1982
If a buck is 4 years old and is still an eight point should I let him walk?
Now that's a whole different issue. I would say that if you are sure of two things here, then take him out:
1) Are you sure that he is 4 years old ?
2) Are you sure that better genetics are present in your herd ?
If yes to both, then take him out.