I have alot of pistols (Glock 21, Colt 1911, CZ75, browning hi power, ect.) I also have several revolvers. I have a Smith model 19, model 27, both .357 mags, and a smith 29 in .44 mag. Also a riger blackhawk in 45 colt. I believe the 357 to be the best defensive cartridge. I shoot my model 27 better than I shoot any other (except possibly the colt). A good revolver is probably the best, most dependable and most maintainence free piece you could get. Especially for beginners Anymore though, a good auto, properly maintained and with the proper ammo is just about as dependable as a revolver. But there is just something about a nice balanced wheelgun. Especially one of the older smiths with thier high luster blueing.
BTW, I am not a cop or anything, and I have never had to use a gun for defense. I have taken a gun away from a hold up man at my store. Luckily, it was a jennings or a high point or some crap and it didn't go off.
okcmco