HuntingNet.com Forums - View Single Post - CWD found in the muscle.
View Single Post
Old 01-29-2006 | 01:56 PM
  #10  
chucker34's Avatar
chucker34
 
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 676
Likes: 0
From: Central Minnesota
Default RE: CWD found in the muscle.

I'd agree that CWD is not going away anytime soon and I'm sure it will eventually make its way into the Minnesota herd. I think taking swift action like you're doing in Wisconsin is about the only solution. I guess its a matter of probably never being able to eradicate it totally, but manage it the best you can to hopefully miniscule levels.

I don't know much about the New Scientist publication. Checked out their web site and seems like they like to take a sensational angle with many of their articles - as do many publications these days. But they did report the testing was done on mice and not people and sometimes those tests are apples to oranges given the amount of the drug or disease the mouse is exposed to. They also mentioned that the muscle tissue given to the mice was only from sick animals, not animals who were simply incubating the disease. So they have not yet determined if that makes a difference.

It will be interesting to see how organizations and other publications who are keeping close tabs on CWD will respond to this new report. One -theChronicWasting Alliance - has a lot of good practical information on its site.

I definitely think CWD is a serious matter but I think we need to review new information like that in the New Scientist carefully before jumping to any conclusions. They haven't proved bird flu can jump from human to human yet but that's all the news media clamored over for weeks/months.

I'd rather be safe than sorry and not find out after the fact that muscle tissue can indeed transfer CWD to humans, but I also don't want to spread fear. Case in point - one of our local news channels did an investigative report during sweeps week claiming a local man died of a brain disease he got from eating CWD infected deer at a Wisconsin game feed. They had his widow on the news crying. Turns out afterward, they belive the disease was the result of something else and the news channel had to correct itself. But that didn't matter, the damage had already been done.
chucker34 is offline  
Reply