Little-d,
The XTPs are outstanding inside 100 yards, we use 300 grainers in my kids gun, but you should have a look at the shockwave ballistics. Same performance on the game, but instead of a drop in the teens at 200 yards, you would have about a 7 inch drop. Both are outstanding sabot rounds and deliver a great punch.
Can't go wrong with either, just get a bit better ballistics w/ the shockwaves.
I won't even address the PB's. If they work good for you in your gun, by all means use them.
R
Hank