I am a convert from a one pieceto a two piece quiver. The main reason is a two piece is much more sturdy and less likely to make noise. The arrows are also much closer to the bow with the two piece quiver making it a slimmer profile.I also like the idea of having a second shot that close though I must admit I have not had the need for it yet with the two piecebut I have had tograb for a second arrow with my one piece over the years.

Having shot all my life with one piecequivers I like them and they do have their pluses, but Iprefer the two piece quivers.Yes with the two piece you do need to take the arrows off of the bow before you store it in your case (unless you have a big soft case), but I found that this was not a problem like I thought it would be. To me the pluses to the two piece quiver out weigh the one piece design. If you like to shoot without a quiver, then this is a no brainer for you but if you always shoot with the quiver attached, give the two piece a try.

Having said that there are many manufactures that make quality two piece quivers. Some are bow specific and others are universal. I can only speek on the type I use (PSE/Browning) Mine are very sturdy, quiet and hold the arrows securely. I like the 4 arrow over the bigger 6 or 8 arrow quivers.

Good luck with your choice.