DD, the only question you have to answer is how much you may need to like the guy in the future. If he is a guy that you don't have tosee in the future and you really think he is to dumb to teach then let him go and learn from it. But if you will have to run into him in the future through your son than maybee it would be best to talk to him. We dont know the guy like you do but just use your judgement. I too would shoot a deer after hours if it was first shot before dark to put it out of its suffering. The only thing that makes me worry about the guy is that he wanted to give up on the blood trail. And also DD i'm a newbe here so I try not to say what I think to much but I like seeing guys speak their mind. I think people are just tired of your super sucess so they have to attack you so you dont look so good. If you hadn't previously posted all those success post you probally wouldn't get the crap that you do, just jealous people. I always like it when you see people preach stuff so hard only to find out in the future they been doing worse then what they preached. also keep up the cool/funny signature pics, you been slackin latley.