Ralpie, What part of the country do you live in?
Charles isn't the only one working this study. Try Auburn University, University of Georgia, Clemson...You need more Ralphie? He has a farm in N.Y.
A far cry from the south were fawns still carry thier spots in September. I have never seen fawns here in Georgia or South Carolina dropped at the same time.
He has never written any thing in stone and lays no claim that this is the rutting bible. Its still a ongoing study with real results.
You should reread what I said. There are a number of other factors involved and quite possibly these are factors that have helped you develope what you see in the woods.
I have records that go back 14 years and by following his formulas he has been very accurate. Not always but closer than I could have ever estimated. And contrary to what you must believe, not all deer mate on November 15th.
One more thing Ralphie....the surveys in Deer & Deer Hunting magazine (the most informative I've seen yet} see to prove his theory as fact more and more every year.

sixpoint40....not 6