Bionicrooster , I didn't shoot her since I won't use a .410 for anything bigger than training kids on squirrels , I was observing while someone else shot her , ironically in an attempt to convince me that the .410 was ok for deer . Reread my post .
Yes , a broadhead may cause greater blood loss initially , but the slug can balance that out with tissue damage and shock , both will fill the lungs with blood . Yes , put a bullet in a lung and it will collapse , ask any emergency room tech . Nobody can guarantee a drop withing 50 yards with any weapon , there are too many variables . Short of a head shot anyway .