Wow, I can't even believe where this thread went. Atlasman, you gotta give it a break bud. You have some serious issues. Oh and btw, Rack-attack did knock the dust off his bow this year. He will have one entered in the contest when he gets his pics done. I don't know exactly what it scored, but I think it was close or would have made P&Yif not for a broken tine. Not real sure why you care about what he kills. ?? Oh, and he got a doe too.

TroopA
That is a nice buck, and most likely ANYONE that was in his shoes would have killed the deer. Yes, it may have come from a pet farm, but who would have ever known that? Great deer, regardless. My opinion, he should get to keep the deer, but not be entered into any record books, should it have qualified.

Tell your friend congrats on a nice deer, and for doing the right thing by questioning the tag.