Interesting thread. It's fun to see the different personality types revealed in such threads. I can tell which hunter's I would probably prefer to hunt with and which ones I wouldn't. Not that one type is wrong and one is right, just some better suited to my temprament and some not.
I thought much the same thing as the thread grew.
The way I see it this thread suffers from trying to define too many different things. Some are describing "proficient" hunters, others "ethical", "successful", and some are describing woodsmanship rather than hunter (although it should be a part of a "good" hunter), while others are describing all-star athlete hunters if not prodigies.
I also agree the thread branched off from it's original intention to include many other aspects as well. Although I am glad it did as it made a rather interesting read and gave us a little insight to some of the other guys mentality.
Seems some guys did not enjoy the thread but I certainly did.