RE: How many people have had luck rattling up a buck?
I rattled ina real nice buck a few years ago. I had made a mock scrape with doe estrus on a ridge the weekend before. Then with a combination of grunting and rattling he came in. I was in my stand from 11:00 until 5:00.I usually rattle little bucks in. My choice is not to rattle but use grunt call with doe estrus.