Option 1 - I assume you mean 3 point minimum - on at least one side. Is enforceable and does ensure the survivalof more than 1/2 of the yearling bucks. I like this simple option at the state level - even if its not biologically the best option.

Option 2 is tough to enforce at the state level - really, really tough in NY

But better biologically maybe because it protects the best of the yearling bucks (most 1st year racks in NY anyhow - will not exceed 13" inside spread).I don't agree witht the spike culling - but if the goal is to increase the genetic potential of the herd - this option is better.

FH