I don't know the whole situation so i couldn't say 'date him rather then the other'. My advice though, in which i agree more with hunterchick with, is you should take in consideration the things you have in common, and whether or not the friendship would be hurt if the dating didn't work. You shouldn't date more then on person at once becauseit'll make things more complexed: For example, it would bemore likely would hurt the friendship with both guys if a dating didn't work with both.As for looks, well, those aren't extremely important. Just my two cents