I'd say the first buck is around 90 inches gross and a younger deer, possibly a big 1 1/2 or a smaller 2 1/2. The second is probably around 110 inches gross and either a decent 2 1/2 or a smaller 3 1/2. They both have good potential, so letting them grow another year or two would be a good choice, but if they're the only two bucks in your area you're seeing then I'd take the bigger one. Every area is different, it's hard to ask others to tell you if you should take them or not. If you'd be proud of the animal then take him, if not let him grow!

Paul