This 125 grain Muzzy killed two deer.

The first a small buck at about 30 yds. Took out one rib on the near side, before exitingind just nicking thelast rib on far side. The deer went about 60yds.

Upon inspection one blade was slightly dull, the other three appeared as sharp as new.

I cleaned it off and nocked it again.

Second deer ,a doe, was standing broadside at 39yds. She wheeled at the shot and the arrow struck the front of the right shoulder blade breaking through it, breaking through the ribs, passing through lungs, liver (and yes smelly parts) exiting the abdomen and entering the left thigh. Deer traveled about 20 yds.

You might tell him to consider a Muzzy. I know lots of people here swear by them, add me to the list.