Personally, I dont think anyone should HAVE to take any does. If you are hunting to manage your herd, thats great. I dont think you should require anyone to shoot a certain amount of does or should you try to bestow your management beliefs on anyone else. If you want to shoot a year and a half old 4 point for meat, I beleive you should be able to.

But on topic, I personally will try to take 3 does and two bucks this year, even though I'm aloud 3 bucks.