I have been using the Cabelas MT050 Gore-Tex Scent-Lok for the past 3 seasons. I buy a new suit every year but still have the forst one I bought. I use it for cold weather fishing and post season scouting / shed hunting. It is as quite and waterproof as ever.
Gore-Tex is a very durable membrane. I have never had any troubles with any Gore-Tex lined clothing.
I did have a DryPlus scent-Lok outfit from Cabelas 4 seasons ago. It rained on opening day and my back and one thigh got soaked

Gore-Tex is far superior to DryPlus.