RE: what would you have done
Well it's kind of a moot point now but I would have asked him what the hell he was doing shooting at a deer that I had already shot. I would have also informed him that I was sorry that he wasted his tag on my deer and removed it.
The animal belongs to the forst person to shoot the animal. And a deer doesn't just decide to take a body roll with out being shot.
That would also be the last itme I hunted with him.
People like that really burn my butt. I have had to finish off an animal or two that another hunter had already shot and I wouldn't have dreamed of tagging it myself. Heck I even helped him drag it out to the truck.