ORIGINAL: shed33
Atlas Atlas Atlas...you so disappoint me...first you dodge my questions
How did I dodge your questions?? You posted a bunch of statements and I asked you to prove them............which you still have not done. I am not dodging anything. I am sinply waiting my turn
then you call my posts names
Well what did you expect??..........I could barely type I was laughing so hard.
whats that say about your true character
That I base my opinions on facts..........and not folklore.
just to let you know...my post is about field testing....yes
its called FIELD TESTING.
Then it is meaningless.............just like I said. Let me rephrase that. It is meaningless to prove that scent suits either work or don't. Typing up a list of deer killed and thanking a scent suit makes about as much sense and thanking your bow or your camo. I think every guy on this board can relate to rolling their eyes when they see a guy shoot a nice buck on TV and then thank his cough silencer for allowing him to get close enough to that deer
Just like I told you already..........there are 1,000 stories of big deer killed without using scent suits..........so does that prove they
don't work???............by your logic it does.
Have you ever field tested a scent lok suit?
Yes.........I have had deer downwind of me every season and never have a problem getting winded...........and I don't wear scent suits.........so I obviously don't need one right??
Have you ever had a mature buck downwind at 20 yards or less that never knew you where there?
Yes
Why would I show you the science...when I already had???
You showed me nothing..........you typed a bunch of things you said that someone else said. No links, no studies, no nothing. I did a google search on your Dr Schlong and found nothing. I'm not saying what you said is not true............I'm saying I have no way of knowing if it is or not.
Atlas, I knew you would dodge my ? and I am finding outits in yournature to dodge questions and call names.
You must be joking............you are the one who has STILL not answered any of my questions to prove what you said about carbon. Stories of how you killed a deer a couple years ago don't prove anything that you said about carbon suits or how they work.
I did supply the science, you called the EXPERT apay off!
Man...........you don't read at all do you? I said I wanted a link to his statements to see what context they were made in. Was it a independent study or was it paid for a carbon suit company to go into a magazine. To my knowledge no company has done a controlled test on scent suits and there abilities to live up to those claims. If you are simply quoting a magazine article............well then we all know how reliable those are
Atlas, the science is here on my desk if you pm me with your home address I will send you the article, for free.
Just give me the link..........If it is a scientific study then I am sure it is on the web. Please don't tell me you are putting all your stock in some old magazine article or op/ed column.
RECAP, I supplied an EXPERTS scientific response to the reactivation versus regeneration.
No you didn't.............you said that some guy said something. Here is how silly that is without proof. I talked to a leading scent suit company and the owner told me his suits are full of used shredded baby diapers. Do you believe that?? Why not?? I typed in on the net so it must be true right??
2nd I offered 7 years of personal field testing in scouting, filming and hunting scenarios. What else do you want.
Meaningless..............1,000 other variables go into each of those situations and to say that a scent suit is what gave you that success is about as silly as saying it was your lucky rabbits foot you carry. Did the suits help you?? Just like the 1,000 guys that could post about the 5,000 deer they killed without scent suits.
If you think killing a deer weraing a suit proves they work then killing a deer without one must prove they don't work right??
I'm sure you will................I just don't agree that your suit is the reason for your success. You sound like a dedicated accomplished hunter..........you should give yourself more credit. In my opinion your hard work is the reason for that list...........not the clothes you wear.