Over the years, I've tried them all. Most work on the little guys. Very few work on older bucks! I used to have great luck with James Valley Scents until he got overloaded with demand. To fulfill this demand, I think he may have diluted the products some. For me, they rarely work anymore. Now I get the ingrediants myself from friends and a butcher and concoct my own....only use it for few weeks in November and then again the first week of December.

Keep us posted if you find one that works for you!