I am w/ PAhunter. I use Bob Kirshner's Curiosity during pre rut and then use SIlvertop during and just after the rut. I have had allot of Bucks come in nose-ing around and even does. I am not particular. After 20+ years I still have found a good recipe for Horns. I am out to put meat in the freezer to feed my family and myself ( and any extra goes to Hunters for the Hungry ) So if Scent gives me an extra edge to do this and it is legal, I am all for it. To each their own. Success in hunting is a personal thing.