I hunt just up the road from you around Troy. We tried the Biologic in a test plot a couple of years ago and got very little response from the deer. Last year I planted about 1 1/4 acre of Buck Blend Oats and the deer liked them a bunch, but they ate them off at the ground just after they came up and by the first of Dec. all I had was a bunch of dirt. We have our best luck planting a mixture of rye, wheat and oats. If it works, why change?