I don't like Hastings because they don't have matte finishes on their barrels.

I have the new Remington 23" "Super Slug" barrel with a matte finish. I would take the matte finish and an inch shorter barrel. Not all deer are going to be sticking their tongue out at you at 150 yds. I would rather get the matte finish just in case a deer came in close, I wouldn't want it being spooked. Just to keep in mind if you have a Remington 12 ga. and want probably the best cantilever barrelfor just out of the factoryguns.