I can only pray they bring AR's to where I hunt.
You guys that are so against it I notice you are from Pike Co, IL. Well duh....you have one of the best herds in the country. Your 1.5yr olds are probably bigger than most of the deer where I hunt. Come and hunt on ground where a 5.5yr old might make p&y....then you'll want AR's.
PA is a prime example that it can and does work. I agree, it may not be the absolute perfect solution....but it is probably the most practical and enforcible one available. Also, I belive PA has a youth law or something...so the young hunters can still take a buck of any size. Maybe someone from PA can elaborate on that, I'm not 100% sure.

I say "Let em go so they can grow!"